From bags:

Birthday Blast Sundae - x 2 pets
Birthday Candy Dispenser - x 1
Blue Lizard Gummy - x 15 pets
Chocolate Party Slice - x 3 pets
Confetti Crunch Sundae - x 3 pets
Gingerbread Candy Shop - x 6 pets
Green 22nd Birthday Candle - x 50 pets
Green Party Pen - x 42 pets
Kujo Bubble Blower - x 55 pets
Origami Decadal Plushie - x 3 and collection
Pool Party Punch - x 3 pets
Purple 22nd Birthday Candle - x50 pets
Rainbow Spring - x 3 pets
Red 22nd Birthday Balloon - x 53 pets
Red Lizard Gummy - x 10 pets
Sand Dollar - x 11 pets
Yellow 22nd Birthday Candle - x 33 pets
Yellow Lizard Gummy - x 4 pets


From pinatas:

Birthday Bash Sundae - x 3 pets
Candy Feather Plushie - x 8 and collection
Green Lizard Gummy - x 24 pets
Ice Cream Chronicles gourmet - x 1
Ice Cream Chronicles book - x 1
Negative Decadal Plushie - x 3 and collection
Party Pop Sundae - x 3 pets
Pineapple Party Punch - x 26 pets
Pink Party Pen - x 23 pets
Purple Lizard Gummy - x 3 pets
Reese Cake Pop - x 3 pets
Rock Around the Clock
Strawberry Party Slice - x 3 pets
Vanilla Party Slice - x 2 pets