As far as I am aware, I can not find where the Transformation Collection keeps track of your pets beginning color/pet. If someone stumbles across this blog, and knows where to find this information, please correct me.

As far as I can remember:

Ellamay- Yellow Fasoro
Ponyoko- Blue Equilor
Kassadee- Green Kaala
Lil_Lioness- Blue Tantua
Seabasstian-Red Grint



These pets were bought/given to me as this color/pet, and therefore I do not know their original status:

Jaise- Chocolate Fasaro
Novasi- Floral Reese