Feel free to use. I've grouped them by event, then alphabetically. If it has an X by it, I have what I need, if not, I still need it. Instruments will have the number I currently have.

Beelzebub:
[X] Beelzebub Stamp
[X] Flaming Shoes
[X] Severed Horn

Pumpkin of Gold:
[X] Candycorn Pencil
[X] Devil Wing Hair Clips
[X] Halloween Pucu Plushie
[X] Plastic Spider Ring
[X] Skeleton Wing Gloves
[X] Skull Candle

Alien:
[X] Armour Top
[X] Cowboy Hat
[X] Ghost Pencil
[X] Peacock Feathers
[X] Plastic Glowing Spider Ring
[X] Red Riding Hood
[X] Trooper Mask

Elger's ToT:
[X] Black Trim School Blazer
[X] Halloween Leido Plushie
[X] Haunted House
[X] Haunted Tree
[X] Little Ghost Story
[X] Plain Pitiful Pigtails Wig
[X] Plastic Blue Spider Ring
[10] Skull Violen
[X] Spider Hat
[X] Spider Web Doughnut
[X] White Trim School Blazer
[X] Witch Pencil
[X] Wolf Hood

Pumpkin Hunt:
Pumpkins:
[X] 2017 Pumpkin
[X] Beige Pumpkin
[X] Big Ears Pumpkin
[X] Big Mouth Pumpkin
[X] Big Teeth Pumpkin
[X] Cursed Pumpkin
[X] Fire Pumpkin
[X] Lilac Pumpkin
[X] Lightning Pumpkin
[X] Magenta Pumpkin
[X] Midnight Pumpkin
[X] Moonlight Pumpkin
[X] Mummy Pumpkin
[X] Nimbus Pumpkin
[X] Snaggletooth Pumpkin
[X] Sparkle Pumpkin
[X] Spider Pumpkin
[X] Starry Eyed Pumpkin
[X] Water Pumpkin
[X] Winter Pumpkin
Others:
[X] Pitiful Pigtails Wig
[X] Police Officer Belt
[X] Police Officer Hat
[X] Police Officer Pants
[X] Police Officer Shirt
[X] Possessed Phonograph
[X] Pumpkin Bath Bomb
[X] Pumpkin Doughnut
[X] Pumpkin Pencil
[X] Pumpkin Shirt
[X] Pumpkin Skirt
[X] Scarecrow Stamp
[X] Trick or Treat Pail
[X] Trumpkin

Snowman:
[X] Crooked Staff
[X] Devil Suit
[X] Feathers
[X] Gourmet Zombie Meal
[X] Gun Holster
[X] Halloween Azul Plushie
[X] Halloween Jacket
[X] Harvest Scythe
[X] Nightmare Glow
[X] Nightmare Top
[X] Pile of Leaves
[X] Plastic Yellow Spider Ring
[x] Skull Wreath
[X] Spooky Doughnut
[X] Spooky Shirt
[x] Vampire Pencil

Character ToT:
[X] Bat Bat
[X] Broken Arm Cast
[X] Candycorn Doughnut
[X] Collared Dress
[X] Frankenstein Pencil
[X] Ghostling
[X] Gothic Harness
[X] Knight Helmet
[X] Plastic Red Spider Ring
[X] Scary Eyes Stamp
[X] Spiced Pumpkin Drink
[10] Spooky Drumset
[X] Spootli
[X] Toddler Overalls
[X] Toddler Sweater
[X] Zombie Hand Stamp
[X] Zombie Jerky
[X] Zombie Plushie