Here are the rare Plushie grabs I have earned from using both the Plushie Machine and the Enchanted Plushie Machine. For the Plushies to qualify, they must be UB at the time of adding them as a blog entry.

Before I started documenting grabs
-Pink Justin Plushie (Can't remember machine)
-Orange Decedal Plushie (Can't remember machine)
-Green Figaro Plushie (Can't remember machine)
-Invisible Astro Plushie (Plushie Machine)

After (Documented Grabs)
You move the claw up...
You picked up Robot Mordo Plushie 26/03/2018
-Enchanted Plushie Machine

You move the claw up...
You picked up Earwig Plushie 26/03/2018
-Enchanted Plushie Machine

08/12/2019
You move the claw to the right...
Enchanted Lilac Basil Plushie is now in your Inventory
(wow, amazing! so happy)

27/09/2022
You move the claw to the left...
You picked up Lilac Kronk Plushie
-Plushie Machine