Bloodmoon Lolly
1 Collected
Book of Cauldrons
1 Collected
Creepy Cat Plushie
1 Collected
Cursed Phantom Four Discs
1 Collected
Elegant Pigtails Hair Extension
1 Collected
For Sale Candle
1 Collected
Magical Girl Staff
1 Collected
Maroon Poera Plushie
1 Collected
Mystery Meat Pyramid
1 Collected
Mystery Meat Sphere
1 Collected
Pile of Skulls
1 Collected
Pumpkin Hair Clip
3 Collected
Sewers Straya Plushie
1 Collected
Skull Hair Clip
3 Collected
Trick or Treat Pail
1 Collected
Vampire Water
1 Collected
Ball of Nightmare Yarn
1 Collected
Creepy Drawing
1 Collected
Damnation Trading Card
1 Collected
Dantiz Plushie
1 Collected
Devil Tantua Skull
1 Collected
Devilray Stamp
1 Collected
Enchanted Nightmare Crindol Plushie
1 Collected
Nacho Problem
1 Collected
Nightmare Costume
1 Collected
Nightmare Osafo Meat
1 Collected
Nightmare Potato
1 Collected
Torment Plushie
1 Collected
Worst Case Scenarios
1 Collected